I was taking a look at couple of RLC's movies reviews and i came across this

Quote: "What we have here are three boring actresses playing three boring characters in one boring movie"

from "http://movie-reviews.colossus.net/movies/j/josie.html"

This was made about Josie and the Pussycats, now i can handle "boring characters or boring movie even (I shudder to think), but "three boring actesses"? I dont know about you, but I feel this guy (James Berardinelli) should be shot.

Sure we're entitled to our own opinion but thats just sick.

Love to know what you all think.

-One disgusted DrunkAss South African.

You just did everything that needs to be done.

Before this I didn't know who James Berardinelli was, and now I'll just ignore anything I see that he writes. If enough people do that, he'll be UNEMPLOYED.

That's real revenge, eh?

Don't make threats (even if they are idle) on the MB. I know you just were making a point, but please be careful. Thanks

-TR

I never care about critics. Unless the contents not what I expected and the movie gets slammed, I always decide for myself...

BTW, critics are meant to be slammed as well, as opinions differ from one another. But we have to keep our distances...

RealLiveClaude
It's cool if you like it, it's okay if you don't, just decide for yourselves...
(Rachael, in "Josie and The Pussycats")

RealLiveClaude is right; who cares about what a critic says ? Sometimes they're right in ones opinion, sometimes they're wrong, so what ?? You can't expect that every movie with RLC is going to be reviewed well, certainly not JATP, which doesn't get a lot of really positive reviews (although not in my country). Off course I enjoy that movie everytime I see it

I humbly apologize for my idle threat.

I'm sure you can see where i was commin from though. Just that he makes these comments and doesn't really substantiate them.

I do apologize, and meant no harm.

-One still disgusted DrunkAss

Aw, James Berardinelli is one of the better 'net-based reviewers, and anyone who's a fan of Roger Ebert's writing style will probably enjoy his reviews. James' comments are more or less in line with most of the critics who ripped into Josie, the vast majority of whom seemed to miss the point of the movie entirely. It doesn't take much to hop from "I dislike this movie" to "I dislike everyone and everything associated with this movie", and I think that's an error he made while reviewing it. Also, I'm not sure how many of Rachael's movies he'd seen (few, I'd guess, judging by the misspelling of her name), but if he thinks of her only as 'the girl from "She's All That"', he may have prematurely dismissed her and her talent with a cursory glance.

Gang,

We are fans of RLC as a person, not so much her films. She could be in Crossroads, and we'd belive it was the best film in the world ever.

Critics are exactly that.. Critical.. that's there job.. but at the end of the day, if a film makes us happy, then why does some critics opinion, who probably has never realised the beauty and charisma of our girl, count towards our opinion/joy/arousal (haha) at watching the film? He probably is a freak, but he's paid to be a critic. If he said Every film ever was brilliant, then there wouldn't be any definition between the films we like, and ..umm.. Crossroads.

Anyhoo.. I see where you all are coming from!
Stand strong for RLC!!

smile.

Yeah! I agree with you all guys! Who cares about critics?.....

Quote: "If doesn't kill you, it only makes you stronger."

-Mark

I'm always wishing the very best for you RLC. You are the most beautiful girl I have ever seen in my entire life.

Mee too, all for it!!!!!!

RACHAEL MARRY ME!!!!!I"M DEAD SERIOUS!!!!!!

Snake

"Age doesn't matter unless your cheese or wine" so rachael MARRY ME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

quote:

---

Originally posted by GreenDay266:
RACHAEL MARRY ME!!!!!I"M DEAD SERIOUS!!!!!!

---

Hmmmm. You're a trying hard overacting fan. Nevermind about it. You are like another Mark(that's me). An overacting fan too. So don't be offended alright? Same feelings.....

-Mark

I'm always wishing the very best for you RLC. You are the most beautiful girl I have ever seen in my entire life.

no no it's all good but i'm not overeacting
i really do want to marry her.
and not in a teenybopper OMYGAWD kinda love but for a real passion i have. But ya know what i'm talking about right?

snake

"Age doesn't matter unless your cheese or wine" so rachael MARRY ME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

quote:

---

Originally posted by GreenDay266:
no no it's all good but i'm not overeacting
i really do want to marry her.

---

LoL! Marry her?(Mark is kinda confused) HeHe. Me too! Hmmm...(Mark is calculating his probability)
About -100% chance of marrying RLC.

Trivia: Do you know that I'm always praying to see RLC in person?

-Mark(LoVe makes the world go round!)

I'm always wishing the very best for you RLC. You are the most beautiful girl I have ever seen in my entire life.

LOL the mark.......
ya well i have 200% chance of marrying her....i know i'm 15 but it doesn't matter.
Well lets not make this anymore then a friendly rivalry. I want her as bad as you do. i'm shure theres pleanty of us. but again.. no i'm not overreacting. Shes the most stunning girl with a great personality i've ever seen so best of luck to you and her!

Snake

"Age doesn't matter unless your cheese or wine" so rachael MARRY ME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Ok Ok! Whatever you say....
GreenDay266 = 15 RLC = 24 w/ a bf.....
Whew!
Quote: "Nothings impossible if you have a faith in it."

-Mark(Nice to meet ya!)

I'm always wishing the very best for you RLC. You are the most beautiful girl I have ever seen in my entire life.

ok cool
sry i don't understand the whole gd266=15rlc=24 w/ bf thing but it's all good!

quote" you don't need harry poter to do magic, all ya need is some love and faith then bam.....anything's possible!!!"

snake

"Age doesn't matter unless your cheese or wine" so rachael MARRY ME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

quote:

---

Originally posted by GreenDay266:
ok cool


quote" you don't need harry poter to do magic, all ya need is some love and faith then bam.....anything's possible!!!"

---

Yeah! You're the man! I like it!

-Mark(this guy over here is amazing!)

I'm always wishing the very best for you RLC. You are the most beautiful girl I have ever seen in my entire life.

no no u the man!!!! lol

it's great we have things like RLC to keep us goin through tough times. She really is an inspiration to me. I'm gonna bet mark too? lol

Snake(some people live to watch RLC, while some watch RLC to live!!!!)

"Age doesn't matter unless your cheese or wine" so rachael MARRY ME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

You're right GreenDay266! LoL!
Sometimes when I have tough problems, I'll just put RLC with it and then....... its solved!

Quote: "What can I do to make you(RLC) love me?"

-Mark(a fan that doesn't give up!)

I'm always wishing the very best for you RLC. You are the most beautiful girl I have ever seen in my entire life.

HA HA LOL that is kinda like w.w.j.d. (what would jesus do) but instead it's like w.w.R.L.C.d. lol (what would Rachael Leigh Cook do) lol ya... okay im finished

Zellio